Best Dog Food for Picky Eaters: Guide 2024

All dog foods are unbiased and nonsponsored. We will not earn from any link.

Feeding a nutritionally balanced diet to picky eaters is struggling for their parents. Meal time becomes a big war room for them. Among all these finding the best dog food for picky eaters is not easy because:

• Dogs are aroma specific.
• Dogs cannot describe their preferences.
• Parents cannot feed only taste-based food. Food should be healthy.

In short, pet parents need tasty and healthy food to stop the food cravings of their fussy eaters. One of the ways to find the right dog food for picky eaters is by using the “Hit and Trial” method or asking your vet.

But….

Why dogs are picky eaters?

Some of the common reasons that are responsible for turning your dear into fussy eaters are:

• Behavioural reasons.
• Medical Issues.
• Develop a strong aroma or taste for food.
• Special preferences.
• Mood

To stop all the worries of the fussy eater’s parents, I am here with a list of 10 well-researched best dog food for picky eaters. At the end of this article, you will get Frequently asked questions to answer common queries.

Let’s start our recommendation.

List of the Best Picky Eaters Dog Food

Certain parameters are used to make this hand-picked list of the best dog food for picky eaters and those are as follows:

• Above 4 stars rating.
• Made in the USA dog food.
• Highest Ratings.
• Follow AAFCO standards.
• The required amount of protein contains.

We are mostly including fresh and raw dog food for your fuzzy eater.

JustFoodForDogs Lamb & Brown Rice Recipe Frozen Human-Grade Fresh Dog Food

Canned foods are the best-tasting dog food due to their natural taste and wild aroma. Among the 7 recipes of JustFoodForDogs, your fussy eater can find his taste in its various delicious recipes. We are reviewing Lamb & Brown Rice. It uses human-grade ingredients to provide premium quality food. 

Lamb & Brown Rice recipe provides 7.5% protein and 72% moisture. It contains fresh veggies and berries. 

The salient features of this recipe are as follows:

• Lamb is the key source of animal protein.
• It contains JFFD Omega plus supplements for healthy skin.
• It is crafted by an expert team of vets, nutritionists, dermatologists, and toxicologists. 

Summarization

Flavor	Lamb & Brown Rice
First 5 ingredients	Lamb, Brown Rice, Cauliflower, Carrots, Lamb Liver
Useful for	All Breed
Ratings	4.3
Price	Click to check the price on Chewy. Click to check the price on Amazon

Pros

• It is free from artificial flavors, preservatives, or colors.
• It does not contain corn, pea, wheat, soy, or grain.
• It is chicken-free.

Cons

• It is costly

Nom Nom Freshly-Made Frozen Turkey Fare Dog Food

pic credit chewy.com

Nom-Nom is known for making fresh-frozen dog foods. Nom Nom crafts real recipes with real taste and flavor. 

It provides 4 delicious recipes to make mealtime happy and healthy. We are reviewing the Turkey recipe. This best dog food for picky eaters provides 10% protein and 72% moisture.

This frozen recipe is easy to digest and vet-approved.

 The features of the Turkey recipe are as follows:

• Turkey is the key source of animal protein.
• It contains real veggies with the right amount of protein.
• It supports stamina.
• It helps healthy digestion.

Summarization

Flavor	Turkey
First 5 ingredients	Turkey, Brown Rice, Eggs, Carrots, Spinach
Useful for	All Breed
Food Type	Frozen
Ratings	4.3
Price	Click to check the price on Chewy.

Pros

• It does not contain fillers, chicken, and peas.
• It is gently cooked.
• It is not processed.

Cons

• Multiple bag sizes are not available.
• There are only 4 recipes.

Freshpet Vital Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Small Breed Fresh Dog Food

Freshpet believes in making food for pets, not pet food. It serves the best ingredients that help in overall body development. The tempting Chicken recipe is crafted specially for your picky eater. The aroma of this recipe attracts your pet and its benefits are enough to attack you.

This best dog food for picky eaters serves 16% protein and 63% moisture. The chicken recipe uses the best ingredients with only farm-raised chicken.

The salient features of this dog food for picky eaters are as follows:

• Chicken is the key source of animal protein.
• It is rich in antioxidants.
• It contains fresh fruits and veggies.
• It contains fatty acids to support healthy skin and a lustrous coat.

Summarization           

Flavor	Chicken
First 5 ingredients	Chicken, Chicken Liver, Carrots, Sweet Potatoes, Pea Protein
Useful for	Small Breed
Food Type	Frozen
Ratings	4.6
Price	Click to check the price on Chewy.

Pros

• It contains non-GMO ingredients.
• It is gently cooked.
• It is grain-free and uses premium ingredients.
• It is free from corn, wheat, or soy.

Cons

• It contains pea.
• Only a few flavors are available. 

Rachael Ray Nutrish Real Beef, Pea, & Brown Rice Recipe Dry Dog Food

The best dry dog food for picky eaters by Racheal Ray believes in providing high-quality ingredient dog food. Its 3 delicious recipes make your dog run for his food bowl. The Beef, Pea, & Brown Rice recipe carefully handpicked all its ingredients to make eating enjoyable and healthy.

This recipe provides 25% protein and other essential nutrients in the required amounts. The recipe claims to fuel up the energy level of your pub and create interest in eating.

The salient features of this recipe are as follows:

• Beef is the key source of animal protein.
• Brown rice makes digestion easy.
• It contains taurine for a healthy heart.
• It is crafted with added minerals and vitamins.
• It supports the immune system through Vitamin C.
• There are fatty acids for healthy skin.

Summarization       

Flavor	Beef, Pea, & Brown Rice
First 5 ingredients	Beef, Beef Meal, Soybean Meal, Whole Corn, Grain Sorghum
Useful for	All Breed
Food Type	Dry
Ratings	4.4
Price	Click to check the price on Chewy .Click to check the price on Amazon

Pros

• It is free from artificial flavors and preservatives.
• It is affordable.
• It comes in various bag sizes.

Cons

• It is not recommended for grain-sensitive dogs
• It contains peas and corn.

Purina ONE Natural SmartBlend Lamb & Rice Formula Dry Dog Food

The Lamb & Rice recipe of Purina One Naturals is crafted at their facilities and uses only purposeful ingredients. This best tasty dry dog food for picky eaters blends the benefits of natural, researched, and nutritionally enriched ingredients. It provides 26% protein. The Lamb & Rice recipe is a 100% completely balanced dog food.

The salient features of this recipe are as follows:

• The real lamb is the key source of animal protein.
• It supports the immune system through antioxidants.
• It contains glucosamine for strong joints.
• It contains probiotic fibers to support the digestive system.

Summarization

Flavor	Lamb & Rice
First 5 ingredients	Lamb, Rice Flour, Whole Grain Corn, Whole Grain Wheat
Useful for	All Breed
Food Type	Dry
Ratings	4.6
Price	Click to check the price on Chewy. Click to check the price on Amazon

Pros

• It is free from fillers.
• It contains all-natural ingredients.
• It is affordable.

Cons

• It contains grain.

Hill’s Science Diet Adult Small Bites Chicken & Barley Recipe Dry Dog Food

Sometimes fussy eaters face food sensitivity problems and are unhappy with regular ingredients. Hill’s Science Diet crafts all its recipes after research and scientific results.

The Chicken and Barley recipe with perfect-sized kibbles is useful for small adult dogs of 1-6 years of age. This best dog food for picky eaters provides 20% protein. 

One customer says that his fussy eater started showing interest in this delicious dog food after he fed her on vet’s recommendation (mentioned on chewy.com).

The salient features of the Chicken and Barley recipe are as follows:

• Chicken is the key source of animal protein.
• It intakes the benefits of grain.
• It is rich in fatty acids to support healthy skin and provide a shiny coat.
• It supports the immune system through antioxidants.
• It contaisn natural fier to support digeative system.
• It contains perfect-sized small kibbles to chew them effortlessly.

Summarization

Flavor	Chicken and Barley
First 5 ingredients	Chicken, Cracked Pearled Barley, Whole Grain Wheat, Whole Grain Corn, Whole Grain Sorghum
Useful for	Small and Extra Small Breed
Food Type	Dry
Ratings	4.7
Price	Click to check the price on Chewy. Click to check the price on Amazon

Pros

• It is free from artificial flavors and preservatives. 
• It does not contain byproduct meals.
• It contains the benefits of grain.
• It is a pet-prescribed recipe.

Cons

• It is costly.
• It has only two flavors.

Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula Adult Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Dry Dog Food

In Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula all 4 recipes used brown rice with different animal sources. The Chicken & Brown Rice recipe is crafted with premium ingredients to make it healthy and tasty. The real chicken in this recipe makes mealtime interesting for your puppy.

This best dog food for picky eaters provides 24% protein with the benefits of real fruits, berries, and veggies.

The salient features of this recipe are as follows:

• Chicken is the key source of animal protein.
• It supports the immune system through antioxidants.
• It contains wholesome grain.
• It has fatty acids to support healthy skin.

Summarization

Flavor	Chicken and Brown Rice
First 5 ingredients	Deboned Chicken, Chicken Meal, Brown Rice, Oatmeal, Barley
Useful for	All Breed
Food Type	Dry
Ratings	4.5
Price	Click to check the price on Chewy. Click to check the price on Amazon

Pros

• It uses natural ingredients.
• It is free from artificial colors or preservatives.
• No poultry by-products are used in this recipe.
• This and all other 4 recipes are free from corn, wheat, or soy.

Cons

• It is not recommended for grain-sensitive dogs.
• It is costly.     

Nature’s Recipe Grain-Free Salmon, Sweet Potato & Pumpkin Recipe Dry Dog Food

Grain-free recipes help in dealing with fussy dogs. These dry dog foods for picky eaters support parents in recreating food taste and nourishing their bodies. The Nature’s Recipe comes in 3 delicious flavors to reintroduce food love in your picky eater.

We are reviewing the Salmon, Sweet Potato & Pumpkin recipe that provides 25% protein, and 4% fiber. This best dog food for picky eaters uses easy-to-digest ingredients to fuel up the energy level of your companion. This delicious dog food for picky eaters is formulated to fulfill the body’s needs for special nutrients.

The salient features of this recipe are as follows:

• It helps to support the digestive system.
• It contains taurine for heart health.
• It contains Omega 6 and Omega 3 fatty acids for healthy skin and a shiny coat.
• It has Vitamine E, and antioxidants to strengthen the immune system.
• With each bowl of this best tasty dry dog food for picky eaters, your pet gets lots of natural fibers.

Summarization

Flavor	Salmon, Sweet Potato & Pumpkin
First 5 ingredients	Salmon, Chicken Meal, Sweet Potatoes, Tapioca Starch, Canola Meal
Useful for	All Breed
Food Type	Dry
Ratings	4.5
Price	Click to check the price on Chewy. Click to check the price on Amazon

Pros

• It is free from artificial colors, preservatives, or flavors.
• It is free from wheat, soy, or corn.
• There are no poultry by-products in any of the 3 recipes.
• It is affordable.

Cons

• It has limited flavors.
• It is not recommended for chicken non-lovers.

CANIDAE Grain-Free PURE Limited Ingredient Bison, Lentil & Carrot Recipe Dry Dog Food

A limited-ingredient diet sometimes helps parents of fussy eaters overcome mealtime struggles, as this diet contains less-allergic foods that can retain the taste and flavor in pets. There are 7 delicious flavors in this best dog food picky eaters.

Yes…

7 flavors can make it easy to find the right choice for your fussy eater. We are reviewing the Bison, Lentils, & Carrot recipe. This best dog food for picky eaters provides 27.5% protein with all essential nutrients. This recipe is crafted with only 10 real ingredients and helps sensitive digestion. 

The salient features of this recipe are as follows:

• Bison is the key source of animal protein.
• It contains wholesome vegetables for easy digestion.
• Probiotics, minerals, vitamins, and antioxidants are added to this recipe to help the immune system.
• It contains fatty acids for healthy skin and a lustrous coat.

Summarization

Flavor	Bison, Lentils, &  Carrot
First 5 ingredients	Bison, Lamb Meal, Sweet Potatoes, Peas, Lentils
Useful for	All Breed
Food Type	Dry
Ratings	4.5
Price	Click to check the price on Chewy. Click to check the price on Amazon

Pros

• There are no artificial colors, preservatives, or flavors.
• It is free from corn, wheat, or soy.
• It has various bag sizes.
• It has many flavors.

Cons

• It contains peas and lentils.

The Honest Kitchen Grain-Free Beef Whole Food Clusters Dry Dog Food

Honest Kitchen believes in delivering perfectly sized cold-pressed kibbles with lots of love and care to make eating interesting and overall body development. Only 100% human-grade ingredients are used in its 3 recipes with wholesome veggies.

We are reviewing the Beef recipe that provides 26% protein. This best dog food for picky eaters has ready-to-eat kibbles for puppies, nursing mothers, and all-breed dogs. It follows high food standards as recommended by vets.

The salient features of this recipe are as follows:

• Beef is the key source of animal protein.
• The kibbles are cold-pressed, dehydrated, and roasted to maintain raw aroma.
• It contains Vitamin E for a strong immune system.
• It has taurine for heart health.

Summarization

Flavor	Beef
First 5 ingredients	Bison, Lamb Meal, Sweet Potatoes, Peas, Lentils
Useful for	All Breed
Food Type	Dry
Ratings	4.5
Price	Click to check the price on Chewy. Click to check the price on Amazon

Pros

• It does not contain any artificial things.
• It is free from soy, corn, wheat, or grain.
• It is chicken-free.
• Non-GMO ingredients are not used in recipes.

Cons

• Limited bag sizes are available.
• It is costly.

Comparison of the Best Dog Food for Picky Eaters

Dog Food	Available Bag Size	Protein Content	Other Flavors	Specification
JustFoodForDogs Lamb & Brown Rice Recipe Frozen Human-Grade Fresh Dog Food	5.5-oz pouch 18-oz pouch 72-oz pouch	7.5%	Beef/Turkey  Beef & Russet Potato Chicken & White Rice Fish & Sweet Potato Lamb & Brown Rice Turkey & Whole Wheat Macaroni Vension & Squash	Excitement at mealtime Improved digestion Increased energy Healthier weight Bight & clear eyes Healthy skin
Nom Nom Freshly-Made Frozen Turkey Fare Dog Food	6.17 pounds	10%	Beef Chicken Pork Turkey	Excitement at mealtime Stamina & energy Healthier weight Healthy poops Healthy skin & coat
Freshpet Vital Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Small Breed Fresh Dog Food	1-lb bag case of 6 1-lb bag case of 12	16%	Chicken	Excitement at mealtime Improved digestion Bight, clear eyes Healthy skin Healthier weight Fresh breath
Purina ONE Natural SmartBlend Lamb & Rice Formula Dry Dog Food	8-lb bag16.5-lb bag31.1-lb bag40-lb bag	26%	Adult-high protein Chicken & Rice Lamb & Rice Large breed
Rachael Ray Nutrish Real Beef, Pea, & Brown Rice Recipe Dry Dog Food	5.5-lb bag 6-lb bag 13-lb bag 14-lb bag 26-lb bag 28-lb bag 40-lb bag 50-lb bag	25%	Beef, Pea, & Brown Rice Chicken & Veggies Turkey, Brown Rice, & Vension	Active Mind Strong Immune System  Healthy skin
Hill’s Science Diet Adult Small Bites Chicken & Barley Recipe Dry Dog Food	4.5-lb bag 5-lb bag 15-lb bag 15.5-lb bag 33-lb bag 35-lb bag 45-lb bag	20%	Chicken & Berley Lamb meal & brown rice	Great Taste Healthy skin and coat Healthy digestion
Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula Adult Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Dry Dog Food	5-lb bag 15-lb bag 24-lb bag 30-lb bag 34-lb bag	24%	Beef & Brown rice Chicken & Brown rice Fish & Brown rice Lamb & Brown rice	High energy level Supports Joint functions Strong Muscles
Nature’s Recipe Grain-Free Salmon, Sweet Potato & Pumpkin Recipe Dry Dog Food	4-lb bag 12-lb bag 24-lb bag 34-lb bag	25%	Chicken, Sweet Potato & Pumpkin Lamb, Sweet Potato & Pumpkin Salmon, Sweet Potato & Pumpkin	Strong Muscles Healthy Digestion Strong Bones and joints Healthy skin & coat Strong immune system Healthy heart Strong teeth
CANIDAE Grain-Free PURE Limited Ingredient Bison, Lentil & Carrot Recipe Dry Dog Food	4-lb bag 10-lb bag 12-lb bag 21-lb bag 22-lb bag	27.5%	Bison, Lentils & carrot Chicken, Lentils & Pea Duck & Sweet Potato Lamb & Sweet Potato Lamb, Goat & Venison Salmon & Sweet Potato Wild boar & garbanzo bean	Healthy heart Strong immune system Healthy digestive system Healthy joints Beautiful skin & coat
The Honest Kitchen Grain-Free Beef Whole Food Clusters Dry Dog Food	1-lb bag 5-lb bag 20-lb bag	26%	Beef Chicken Turkey	Healthy heart Healthy digestive system Mealtime satisfaction

Tips to Buy the Best Dog Food for Picky Eaters

• Use the trial method to figure out the taste.
• Use different flavors and food textures.
• Use good quality dog food.
• Use grain-free dog food.
• Consult your vet.
• Use limited-ingredient dog food.
• Use fresh and natural dog food.

Conclusion

Picky eaters can be dealt with by making more effort and finding the right food choice. Along with the taste, healthy dog food with all essential nutrients is a must for them. Carefully examine the behavioral changes in your dog and if needed go to the vet to figure out the true cause of his food discomfort.

This article will help you find tasty and healthy dog foods that convert your feeding struggle into enjoyable memories.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)